
It has been a busy concerto summer here in Cleveland, for our orchestra had
to play the final rounds of two international competitions on top of
accompanying our own guest artists. It was exciting to hear the competitors
both in rehearsal and performance, and also to see the difference between
up-and-coming young artists and seasoned performers with the same
orchestra.
The first competition was the Cleveland International Piano Competition, and
it lasted for 10 days, culminating in the performance of four finalists with
The Cleveland Orchestra. I was very happy to hear four very different players
in the finals, especially as the common criticism is that these days all the
players sound the same.
The winner was Alexander Schimpf from Germany, and his finals piece was
Beethoven's 4th piano concerto. He seemed an intelligent and energetic
performer! Second prize went to Russia, to Aleksey Chernov who played Brahms'
first piano concerto. From the first moment in the rehearsal it seemed that he
is very familiar with the orchestra part and can perform with confidence. He
seemed a bit nervous in the performance though, and it was interesting to see
how the fourth prize winner Kyu Yeon Kim (South Korea) played the same
concerto. She seemed to be not as much at ease with the orchestra, but during
her cadenzas she played with much more freedom than Chernov! Third prize went
to Eric Zuber (USA) who played a strong though a little hectic account of the
Rachmaninov 2nd concerto.
Just a week after the piano competition we had the pleasure to work with
Yuja Wang who despite being only in her twenties is an experienced performer
with a huge repertoire and a busy schedule. Between her and the four
competitors I heard there was no competition, really! She set herself apart
already by her confidence and calmness since the very first rehearsal. Small
things make a real professional!
Yuja played Prokofiev's third piano concerto with us in Blossom, and she was
very well received by our enthusiastic festival audience. For me it was just
wonderful to watch how her hands were flying over the keyboard with apparent
ease, while knowing how devilishly difficult the piece is. My fellow blogger
Lincoln wrote a very nice piece about the concert -
check it out here!
Our second competition was the Cooper International Competition which
alternates between violin and piano every year. It is intended to very young
performers as the upper age limit is 18. The competition is organized by the
Oberlin Conservatory and all the finalists are guaranteed a free ride if they
decide to study in Obelin for their undergraduate studies.
We heard three very young and very talented violinists play three very
different pieces - Prokofiev's second concerto, the Mendelssohn violin concerto
and the Sibelius violin concerto. When the players are this young it is hard to
tell whether the interpretation comes from them or from their teacher, but what
surprised me was how out of style the Mendelssohn sounded to me, with
aggressive tone and all the cliché rubatos you could possibly put there. Even
more it surprised me that the jury thought the interpretation worth the top
prize! I guess I shouldn't be surprised having gone through a dozen conducting
competitions, but still I found it strange that some people - professional
musicians - could hear the music so differently from me. Probably that means
that I should keep Mendelssohn out of my concert programs no matter how much I
love him...
As a final word about violinists, two weeks ago Baiba Skride came to
Cleveland to perform the Bruch concerto at Blossom. Sweet tone, solid technique
and a calm presence on stage without any crowd pleasing histrionics. Again, she
would have been a good role model for the young competitors! I sometimes wonder
who are the young violinists listening to - and watching - with their strange
stage manner. Maybe it's just the sign of the times?